November Is the Best Month to Cold Call. December Is the Worst.
November was our best month to cold call last year and December cut our bookings in half. Here's what we saw and what to do with the next six weeks.

By Cavin Sherman
Every year around this time I get the same call from a prospect. “Let’s just pick it back up in January.” Nobody’s answering, nobody’s buying, budgets are done, so why spend money on outbound in Q4?
And I get it. But I went back and pulled our numbers from last year, and November was the best month we had in all of 2025. By a lot.
So what did the numbers say?
This is every Exodus campaign, counting one meeting per person booked. The number in brackets is meetings booked per 100 conversations:
Month | Booked (per 100 convos) |
|---|---|
Oct 2025 | 124 (4.0) |
Nov 2025 | 182 (5.0) |
Dec 2025 | 69 (2.2) |
Jan 2026 | 85 (2.9) |
November beat October by almost 50%. Part of that is we dialed more. But the rate went up too. For every 100 people who actually picked up and talked to one of our reps, we booked 5 meetings in November and 4 in October.
Then December fell off a cliff. Less than half the meetings, and the rate per conversation got cut in half. To be fair we had fewer reps on the phones in December, 66 vs 77, but that doesn’t take a booking rate from 5 to 2. People were still picking up. They just weren’t saying yes.
And January didn’t snap back the way everybody says it will. 85 meetings. Better than December, nowhere close to November.
Why does November work?
I went over this with my team at the start of the month, and these are the reasons I gave them.
Next year’s budgets are getting set right now, and whatever’s left in this year’s budget is use it or lose it. Somebody in that building is trying to spend it before December 31.
A lot of contracts renew in January. If a company is going to switch vendors, that conversation has to happen before the renewal, so it’s happening now.
Conference and travel season is over. People are actually at their desks.
And a lot of reps just stop dialing. Everybody’s coasting into the holidays, so the person you call isn’t getting hit by five other SDRs that same day. More fresh data for you and way less noise.
One of my reps keeps his own numbers going back five years. He told the team August is always his worst month and Q4 is where he makes all his money.
Make the time of year your reason for calling
When COVID hit I was an SDR booking about 5.6 demos a day. A few weeks later I was at like one. Everybody’s numbers dropped except one guy. We called him TV Dad because he sounded like a dad on the phone, dad jokes and all, and his numbers went up. He didn’t pretend nothing was going on. He built his whole pitch around it, asked people how they were holding up, and made what was happening in the world the reason to talk.
Same thing works at the end of the year. Earlier this month one of my reps changed a couple of lines in his script. He added “I know you’re probably all over the place with the end of year push” to his opener, and a line about how this time of year everybody’s tallying up their numbers, and that number is exactly what they’re trying to shrink in 2027. He booked a meeting about 30 minutes later. He said himself that could just be wild timing. But now the prospect feels like there’s an actual reason you’re calling today, and on a cold call that’s huge.
If you’ve got an outbound team or an agency running right now, ask them what changed in the script for Q4. If the answer is nothing, start there.
So how should you cold call in December?
I don’t tell clients to shut it off. I tell them to taper the expectations.
Book as much as you can before the middle of the month. For the meetings that land in January you have to double tap them. Somebody says Christmas is bad, let’s do the second week of January, fine. Send the invite while they’re still on the phone, then confirm again the first week back. On our own campaigns, meetings booked more than a week out show up a lot less than the ones booked inside a week, and a meeting a month out with no follow-up usually just doesn’t happen.
The good part is January calendars are empty. Whoever gets on the calendar for the first week back gets that prospect before their inbox fills up again.
So should you pause until January?
If we’d done what everybody says and waited for January, we would’ve skipped the best month of our year to save money in the worst one.
Dial hard through November, keep going into December with lower expectations, and get your January meetings locked in before everybody leaves for the holidays.
If you want to see what the next six weeks could look like for your team, grab a time with me.

